Hiring a new executive is one of the most important decisions your organization will make. The right leader can boost growth, strengthen culture, and set the tone for long-term success. Alternatively, the wrong hire can cost time, money, and momentum.
Before engaging an executive search firm, it’s important to ask: Is your organization truly ready for executive search? This guide offers the key areas to evaluate and shows how partnering with a trusted firm like Acumen Executive Search can help you prepare if you’re not quite there yet.
1. Clarity on Strategic Goals
A successful executive hire begins with strategy.
- Do you have a clear vision and roadmap for the next 3 – 5 years?
- What role will this leader play in reaching those goals?
Not there yet? Acumen works with boards and leadership teams to define priorities and ensure the role aligns with long-term objectives.
2. Defined Role and Expectations
Top candidates want to know what the expectations are of the role and the level of impact they will have.
- What are the key responsibilities for this role?
- How will success be measured in the first 12 months?
If these are still evolving, Acumen can help clarify the role, create a compelling job description, and shape the opportunity to attract the right talent.
3. Organizational Alignment
It is critical that the leadership team and/or board agree on the priorities for the role.
- Is your team aligned on qualifications, leadership style, and cultural fit?
- Will the new leader have the authority and support they need to succeed?
Acumen often facilitates this alignment. For example, when one organization came to Acumen after a failed search with another firm, stakeholder interviews revealed that there were many different opinions as to what was important in a new CEO. Acumen guided the leadership team through discussions to reach consensus, which yielded a successful hire.
4. Culture and Employer Brand
Many top candidates are currently working. Why would someone leave their current position to join your organization?
- Can you clearly articulate your culture and values?
- Is your employer brand attractive to high-caliber leaders?
If these aren’t well defined, Acumen helps uncover what makes your organization unique and why the opportunity is attractive.
5. Compensation and Market Readiness
Compensation must align with the current market.
- Have you compared against similar roles in your industry?
- Are you prepared to offer a competitive package?
Acumen provides compensation insights to ensure your offer is competitive. In one recent search, Acumen advised on getting a valuation for an equity stake for a President role, helping the client create an attractive package to retain the right leader.
Executive search requires commitment and collaboration.
6. Time, Commitment, and Resources
- Are your decision-makers available to participate in interviews and evaluations?
- Do you have a clear timeline for the hire?
If bandwidth is limited, Acumen manages the process while keeping decision-makers engaged at the right moments. From developing tailored interview questions to moderating panel interviews and creating scoring mechanisms, Acumen ensures structure and momentum throughout the search.
7. Transition and Onboarding Plan
Once an offer is accepted, there is still work to do.
- Do you have a clear onboarding plan for the first 90 days?
- How will you keep the new hire engaged until their start date?
Acumen guides organizations in building transition plans that set up a new executive for success and keep them engaged between acceptance and day one.
Final Thought on Executive Search
If you can confidently answer “yes” to these questions, your organization is prepared to launch an executive search. If not, you’re not alone, and you don’t have to figure it out by yourself.
At Acumen Executive Search, we go beyond filling roles. We are trusted advisors, helping organizations clarify strategy, align stakeholders, refine roles, and prepare to attract and retain exceptional leaders. When the stakes are this high, you deserve a partner who ensures you’re truly ready to make the right hire – not just for today, but for the future as well.
Be sure to like and follow our podcast, Hiring for Good,